-
It has come to the attention of forum staff that Dollshe Craft has ceased communications with dealers and customers, has failed to provide promised refunds for the excessive waits, and now has wait times surpassing 5 years in some cases. Forum staff are also concerned as there are claims being put forth that Dollshe plans to close down their doll making company. Due to the instability of the company, the lack of communication, the lack of promised refunds, and the wait times now surpassing 5 years, we strongly urge members to research the current state of this company very carefully and thoroughly before deciding to place an order. For more information please see the Dollshe waiting room. Do not assume this cannot happen to you or that your order will be different.Dismiss Notice
-
Dollshe Craft and all dolls created by Dollshe, including any dolls created under his new or future companies, including Club Coco BJD are now banned from Den of Angels. Dollshe and the sculptor may not advertise his products on this forum. Sales may not be discussed, no news threads may be posted regarding new releases. This ban does not impact any dolls by Dollshe ordered by November 8, 2023. Any dolls ordered after November 8, 2023, regardless of the date the sculpt was released, are banned from this forum as are any dolls released under his new or future companies including but not limited to Club Coco BJD. This ban does not apply to other company dolls cast by Dollshe as part of a casting agreement between him and the actual sculpt or company and those dolls may still be discussed on the forum. Please come to Ask the Moderators if you have any questions.Dismiss Notice
Difference between revisions of "off-topic"
From Den of Angels BJD Wiki
(→Off-topic by 2013 Criteria Update) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Den of Angels is dedicated to the discussion of resin ball-jointed dolls. A doll's suitability for Den of Angels is determined based on several [http://www.denofangels.com/forums/showthread.php?42407-Criteria-for-Dolls-quot-On-Topic-quot-for-DoA criteria points]. Ultimately, the decision is solely up to the moderators. | Den of Angels is dedicated to the discussion of resin ball-jointed dolls. A doll's suitability for Den of Angels is determined based on several [http://www.denofangels.com/forums/showthread.php?42407-Criteria-for-Dolls-quot-On-Topic-quot-for-DoA criteria points]. Ultimately, the decision is solely up to the moderators. | ||
| − | + | ||
'''Off-topic dolls may not be bought, sold, or traded on Den of Angels. They may not be the sole focus of any thread or post, though they may be included as comparisons in discussion with on-topic dolls, and they may be posted in the gallery in photographs that feature on-topic dolls but not alone in photos.''' | '''Off-topic dolls may not be bought, sold, or traded on Den of Angels. They may not be the sole focus of any thread or post, though they may be included as comparisons in discussion with on-topic dolls, and they may be posted in the gallery in photographs that feature on-topic dolls but not alone in photos.''' | ||
| − | + | ||
This is not a comprehensive list of the dolls that are off topic, but these are some dolls that have caused some confusion. They have been discussed and specifically disallowed by the moderators: | This is not a comprehensive list of the dolls that are off topic, but these are some dolls that have caused some confusion. They have been discussed and specifically disallowed by the moderators: | ||
| − | + | ||
==Non-resin dolls== | ==Non-resin dolls== | ||
| − | + | The following dolls are off topic due to being made of plastic, porcelain, silicon or another material: | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | * Barbie, Bratz, Moxie Girlz, Monster High, etc. | |
| − | * | + | * Gene, Tyler, Horsman Urban Vita, Fashion Royalty, Cygirls |
| − | * | + | * Mattel Teen Trends |
| − | * | + | * Mooqla |
| − | * | + | * Pullip, Dal, Taeyang, Namu, Byul, Isul, Hestia, J-dolls and Ai Dolls |
| − | * Pullip, Dal, Taeyang, Namu, Byul, Isul, Hestia | + | * Blythe, Jenny & Licca |
| − | * | + | * [[Volks]] and [[Obitsu]] 1/6 plastic/vinyl dolls |
| − | * [[Volks]] | + | * InMotion Strawberina dolls (ABS plastic) |
| − | * | + | * JerryBerry dolls (plastic body) |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
* [[Azone International]] vinyl dolls (these dolls have rooted hair and painted on features) - Although Obitsu bodies (60cm, 50cm, 48cm, 40cm) are Grandfathered, heads with rooted hair and painted features are not. Hybrids of off-topic and on-topic/Grandfathered parts are considered to be off-topic in their entirety. | * [[Azone International]] vinyl dolls (these dolls have rooted hair and painted on features) - Although Obitsu bodies (60cm, 50cm, 48cm, 40cm) are Grandfathered, heads with rooted hair and painted features are not. Hybrids of off-topic and on-topic/Grandfathered parts are considered to be off-topic in their entirety. | ||
| − | + | * Momoko & Momoko collaboration [[Unoa Lights]] (resin Unoa Lights are on topic) | |
| + | * [[Dollmoe]] ABS/PVC dolls, including non-resin dolls in the ‘FMD’ and ‘Basic Gem’ lines (resin dolls may be on topic) | ||
* [[Custom House/AI]] vinyl dolls (resin dolls may be on topic) | * [[Custom House/AI]] vinyl dolls (resin dolls may be on topic) | ||
* [[Doll in Mind]] vinyl dolls (resin dolls may be on topic) | * [[Doll in Mind]] vinyl dolls (resin dolls may be on topic) | ||
| − | * Enchanted Doll (porcelain | + | * Hujoo ABS plastic dolls (resin dolls may be on topic) |
| − | * [[ | + | * Enchanted Doll (porcelain) |
| − | * | + | * [[Angel Egg Dolls]] by Marmite Sue (porcelain; resin dolls may be on topic) |
| − | * | + | * [[Linda Macario]] (porcelain; resin dolls may be on topic) |
| − | * | + | * Silicone babies, polymer figurines, action figures, figure kits, gachapon, etc. |
| − | * | + | |
| − | * | + | ==Dolls off-topic by construction== |
| − | * | + | * [[Angel Egg Dolls]] by Marmite Sue bodies that have a spring tension system |
| − | * [[ | + | * [[Angelsdoll]] Iseul Cat Avatar (not ball-jointed) |
| + | *[[Danny Choo]] Smartdoll Mirai (internal skeleton, not strung) | ||
| + | * [[Doll In Mind]] DIM Sweet line, including Aria, Trisha, etc. (swivel neck joint only) | ||
| + | * [[Dollmore]] Dummy (not enough joints) | ||
| + | * [[Dollzone]] 2009 Christmas babies (no wrist joint) | ||
| + | * [[Dollzone]] 2012 Event dolls Fa, Mi, Re and Do on the small body (not enough joints; heads on the alternative 12cm body are on topic) | ||
| + | * [[Dreamhigh Studios|Dream High Studio]] Sylph (pin and hinge joints) | ||
| + | * Enchanted Doll (resin dolls aren't strung & have painted eyes) | ||
| + | * [[Heisejinyao Ziyulinglong]] (HZ) Bloaties (Roro Line) (not enough joints) | ||
| + | * [[Herrendoll]] Bambola (not enough joints) | ||
| + | * [[IMPLdoll|Impldoll]] Fantasy Doll: Demi & Aemi {Forest Story}(On-topic on their human bodies) | ||
| + | * [[Iplehouse]] N.YID Bianca v2 Cyborg (eyes cannot be changed) | ||
| + | * [[Leekeworld]] Kindergarten K-type Friends (not enough limb joints) | ||
| + | * [[Loongsoul|LoongSoul]] Amalthea (non-jointed from the waist down) | ||
| + | * [[Lumedoll]] Zero (no face, no eye openings, not capable of eye-changing) | ||
| + | * [[Luts]] Tiny Delf Fairies Hansel and Gretel (no wrist joints) | ||
| + | * [[Mushroom Peddler]] (finish not up to par) | ||
| + | * [[My Dolling]] MJ Koo (not ball-jointed in hands and wrists) | ||
| + | * [[Notdoll Lab|NotDoll Lab/Aeyork]] Just Venus, Aka Bomb (not enough joints) | ||
| + | * [[PeaksWoods]] Sun Fairy Shu Shu and all Monthly Fairy Dolls (non-jointed bodies) | ||
| + | * [[Popovy Sisters]] Bony, Blue Jay, Cherry, Cuckoo, Magpie (painted eyes) | ||
| + | * [[Simply Divine]] [[Steinsculpture]] Frozen Charlotte and West Nile Charlotte (tiny bird skull version) (not enough joints, head is not 2-part, eyes are not removable) | ||
| + | * [[Soom]] Nappy Choo | ||
| + | * [[Spirit Doll]] Herber (March Hare) and Bloom (rabbit) (unjointed legs) | ||
| + | * [[Volks]] Customize Figure kits (plastic parts, not strung) | ||
| − | == | + | ==Off-topic resin fashion dolls== |
| − | Although made of resin, these | + | Although made of resin, these fashion dolls are off topic: |
* Dawn D'onofrio doll Raven | * Dawn D'onofrio doll Raven | ||
* Doll in Paris | * Doll in Paris | ||
| − | |||
* Dollmore Lukia Dolls | * Dollmore Lukia Dolls | ||
* Ellowyne Wilde | * Ellowyne Wilde | ||
* Evangeline Ghastly | * Evangeline Ghastly | ||
* FICON | * FICON | ||
| − | * | + | *JamieSHOW (male and female) |
* Kinetics | * Kinetics | ||
* RnD Angels & Mensajero Dolls | * RnD Angels & Mensajero Dolls | ||
* Sybarites | * Sybarites | ||
| − | ==Off-topic | + | ==Off-topic for other reasons== |
| − | *[[Bergemann Dolls|Bo Bergemann]] Sugar | + | *[[Bergemann Dolls|Bo Bergemann]] Sugar Babies (infant dolls with realistically sculpted baby fat) |
| − | + | *[[D-Storic]] IZI and future 'God size' dolls (life-sized 1:1 scale dolls) | |
| − | *[[D-Storic]] IZI and future 'God size' dolls | + | *[[Jakzjewels]] Be'Be' type Casimira |
| − | + | *[[Leekeworld]] Little Mermaid (human & mermaid versions) (painted-on underwear on human version) | |
| − | + | *[[Leekeworld]] Little Bird (human & bird versions) | |
| − | + | *[[Magical Angel]] Iris (life-sized 1:1 scale doll) | |
| − | *[[Jakzjewels]] | + | *[[MocaPinoRu]] (minimally sculpted body) |
| − | + | *[[Neo Angel Region]] Nappy Choo, Hallow Baby Choo, Sweet Baby Choo, Popo, Dalang (infant dolls with realistically sculpted baby fat) | |
| − | *[[Leekeworld]] Little Mermaid ( | + | *[[Papermoon]] Chii (life-sized 1:1 scale dolls) |
| − | *[[Leekeworld]] Little Bird ( | + | *[[Ringdoll]] Fat Peanut and Children's Day 2013 'Comic' event head (no eye holes, no anatomical features) |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | *[[Magical Angel]] Iris | + | |
| − | *[[MocaPinoRu]] | + | |
| − | *[[Neo Angel Region]] Nappy Choo, Hallow Baby Choo, Sweet Baby Choo, Popo, Dalang | + | |
| − | *[[Papermoon]] Chii | + | |
| − | *[[Ringdoll]] Children's Day 2013 'Comic' event head (no eye holes, no anatomical features) | + | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| + | ==Off-topic anthro/animal dolls== | ||
Some off-topic anthros are still allowed in the marketplace as [http://www.denofangels.com/forums/showthread.php/108523-Marketplace-Access-Requirements-amp-Rules?p=6290242&viewfull=1#post6290242 accessory companions]. | Some off-topic anthros are still allowed in the marketplace as [http://www.denofangels.com/forums/showthread.php/108523-Marketplace-Access-Requirements-amp-Rules?p=6290242&viewfull=1#post6290242 accessory companions]. | ||
| Line 99: | Line 103: | ||
* [[Doll Chateau]] Faramita (bull) | * [[Doll Chateau]] Faramita (bull) | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
* [[Dollzone]] Elephant, Dog, Gugu (plant), Lulu (plant) | * [[Dollzone]] Elephant, Dog, Gugu (plant), Lulu (plant) | ||
| Line 118: | Line 120: | ||
* [[Luts]] Minimee Zuzu Delf figurines | * [[Luts]] Minimee Zuzu Delf figurines | ||
| − | * [[MisticUnicorn]] [[The Mushroom Peddler]] Wonderlings (various animals), Mini-Wonderlings (various animals | + | * [[MisticUnicorn]] [[The Mushroom Peddler]] Wonderlings (various animals), Mini-Wonderlings (various animals; textured resin, more animal than anthro), Spark the Wyvern (dragon), Buglings (various insects, lack required joints) |
* [[Tendres de Chimère]] Zouïe (fish), Fenouil (rabbit) | * [[Tendres de Chimère]] Zouïe (fish), Fenouil (rabbit) | ||
| Line 125: | Line 127: | ||
* [[Wilde Imagination]] Mouette (skunk) | * [[Wilde Imagination]] Mouette (skunk) | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
==Artist dolls== | ==Artist dolls== | ||
All dolls allowed on Den of Angels must adhere to the [http://www.denofangels.com/forums/content.php?203 forum criteria]. Artists who have created dolls in resin should post in [http://www.denofangels.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?14 Ask the Moderators]] with information about their dolls before posting them on the forum. | All dolls allowed on Den of Angels must adhere to the [http://www.denofangels.com/forums/content.php?203 forum criteria]. Artists who have created dolls in resin should post in [http://www.denofangels.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?14 Ask the Moderators]] with information about their dolls before posting them on the forum. | ||
| − | + | ||
Being listed as off-topic does not imply a negative judgment against the makers or sculpts. They simply do not fit the focus of our forum and have been ruled off-topic. Forums to discuss them: [http://milkshakemelody.com/forum/ Lunar Ark], [http://www.junkyspot.com/OBITSU/forums/ Junky Spot], [http://blythekingdom.forumotion.com/ Blythe Kingdom] | Being listed as off-topic does not imply a negative judgment against the makers or sculpts. They simply do not fit the focus of our forum and have been ruled off-topic. Forums to discuss them: [http://milkshakemelody.com/forum/ Lunar Ark], [http://www.junkyspot.com/OBITSU/forums/ Junky Spot], [http://blythekingdom.forumotion.com/ Blythe Kingdom] | ||
Revision as of 15:59, 17 January 2015
Den of Angels is dedicated to the discussion of resin ball-jointed dolls. A doll's suitability for Den of Angels is determined based on several criteria points. Ultimately, the decision is solely up to the moderators.
Off-topic dolls may not be bought, sold, or traded on Den of Angels. They may not be the sole focus of any thread or post, though they may be included as comparisons in discussion with on-topic dolls, and they may be posted in the gallery in photographs that feature on-topic dolls but not alone in photos.
This is not a comprehensive list of the dolls that are off topic, but these are some dolls that have caused some confusion. They have been discussed and specifically disallowed by the moderators:
Contents
Non-resin dolls
The following dolls are off topic due to being made of plastic, porcelain, silicon or another material:
- Barbie, Bratz, Moxie Girlz, Monster High, etc.
- Gene, Tyler, Horsman Urban Vita, Fashion Royalty, Cygirls
- Mattel Teen Trends
- Mooqla
- Pullip, Dal, Taeyang, Namu, Byul, Isul, Hestia, J-dolls and Ai Dolls
- Blythe, Jenny & Licca
- Volks and Obitsu 1/6 plastic/vinyl dolls
- InMotion Strawberina dolls (ABS plastic)
- JerryBerry dolls (plastic body)
- Azone International vinyl dolls (these dolls have rooted hair and painted on features) - Although Obitsu bodies (60cm, 50cm, 48cm, 40cm) are Grandfathered, heads with rooted hair and painted features are not. Hybrids of off-topic and on-topic/Grandfathered parts are considered to be off-topic in their entirety.
- Momoko & Momoko collaboration Unoa Lights (resin Unoa Lights are on topic)
- Dollmoe ABS/PVC dolls, including non-resin dolls in the ‘FMD’ and ‘Basic Gem’ lines (resin dolls may be on topic)
- Custom House/AI vinyl dolls (resin dolls may be on topic)
- Doll in Mind vinyl dolls (resin dolls may be on topic)
- Hujoo ABS plastic dolls (resin dolls may be on topic)
- Enchanted Doll (porcelain)
- Angel Egg Dolls by Marmite Sue (porcelain; resin dolls may be on topic)
- Linda Macario (porcelain; resin dolls may be on topic)
- Silicone babies, polymer figurines, action figures, figure kits, gachapon, etc.
Dolls off-topic by construction
- Angel Egg Dolls by Marmite Sue bodies that have a spring tension system
- Angelsdoll Iseul Cat Avatar (not ball-jointed)
- Danny Choo Smartdoll Mirai (internal skeleton, not strung)
- Doll In Mind DIM Sweet line, including Aria, Trisha, etc. (swivel neck joint only)
- Dollmore Dummy (not enough joints)
- Dollzone 2009 Christmas babies (no wrist joint)
- Dollzone 2012 Event dolls Fa, Mi, Re and Do on the small body (not enough joints; heads on the alternative 12cm body are on topic)
- Dream High Studio Sylph (pin and hinge joints)
- Enchanted Doll (resin dolls aren't strung & have painted eyes)
- Heisejinyao Ziyulinglong (HZ) Bloaties (Roro Line) (not enough joints)
- Herrendoll Bambola (not enough joints)
- Impldoll Fantasy Doll: Demi & Aemi {Forest Story}(On-topic on their human bodies)
- Iplehouse N.YID Bianca v2 Cyborg (eyes cannot be changed)
- Leekeworld Kindergarten K-type Friends (not enough limb joints)
- LoongSoul Amalthea (non-jointed from the waist down)
- Lumedoll Zero (no face, no eye openings, not capable of eye-changing)
- Luts Tiny Delf Fairies Hansel and Gretel (no wrist joints)
- Mushroom Peddler (finish not up to par)
- My Dolling MJ Koo (not ball-jointed in hands and wrists)
- NotDoll Lab/Aeyork Just Venus, Aka Bomb (not enough joints)
- PeaksWoods Sun Fairy Shu Shu and all Monthly Fairy Dolls (non-jointed bodies)
- Popovy Sisters Bony, Blue Jay, Cherry, Cuckoo, Magpie (painted eyes)
- Simply Divine Steinsculpture Frozen Charlotte and West Nile Charlotte (tiny bird skull version) (not enough joints, head is not 2-part, eyes are not removable)
- Soom Nappy Choo
- Spirit Doll Herber (March Hare) and Bloom (rabbit) (unjointed legs)
- Volks Customize Figure kits (plastic parts, not strung)
Off-topic resin fashion dolls
Although made of resin, these fashion dolls are off topic:
- Dawn D'onofrio doll Raven
- Doll in Paris
- Dollmore Lukia Dolls
- Ellowyne Wilde
- Evangeline Ghastly
- FICON
- JamieSHOW (male and female)
- Kinetics
- RnD Angels & Mensajero Dolls
- Sybarites
Off-topic for other reasons
- Bo Bergemann Sugar Babies (infant dolls with realistically sculpted baby fat)
- D-Storic IZI and future 'God size' dolls (life-sized 1:1 scale dolls)
- Jakzjewels Be'Be' type Casimira
- Leekeworld Little Mermaid (human & mermaid versions) (painted-on underwear on human version)
- Leekeworld Little Bird (human & bird versions)
- Magical Angel Iris (life-sized 1:1 scale doll)
- MocaPinoRu (minimally sculpted body)
- Neo Angel Region Nappy Choo, Hallow Baby Choo, Sweet Baby Choo, Popo, Dalang (infant dolls with realistically sculpted baby fat)
- Papermoon Chii (life-sized 1:1 scale dolls)
- Ringdoll Fat Peanut and Children's Day 2013 'Comic' event head (no eye holes, no anatomical features)
Off-topic anthro/animal dolls
Some off-topic anthros are still allowed in the marketplace as accessory companions.
- 42dolls Nyangi (cat), Ppuggu (dog), Tori (rabbit), Chu (bear), Ggumi (pig); lack required joints
- Aileen Doll / Hujoo Sunny (cat), Dorothy (cat), Bubi (cat), Wawa (dog), Frank (dog), Duboo (dog), Ashes (dragon), Seed (dragon), Rot (dragon), Genie (fox), Penny (fox); lack required joints
- Asleep Eidolon PongPong (panda)
- Blitzava/SheJackal Unicorn, Jackal, and Dinosaur
- Buddydoll Joy (dog)
- Camellia Dynasty Mokona
- Charles Creature Cabinet Boneka Kayu, Issa (faun), Jemmy (faun), Kimbo (faun), Emiko (merbaby), Issa Moriko (Woodling baby), Imaginary Friend IF
- CocoTribe Peter (pig), Christine (cat) (both only come closed-eyed, no option for open-eye heads that can take interchangeable eyes.
- Dikadoll Mianmian (cat)
- Doll Chateau Faramita (bull)
- Dollzone Elephant, Dog, Gugu (plant), Lulu (plant)
- Domuya Bat
- Dreamingdoll Baron (dog)
- Dream Realms anthros
- Elfdoll Idex bunny, Seedlings (Sissy 1, 2 & 3), Baby Alice (piglet), Baby Ian (piglet), Edward (mouse)
- Goodreau Bear (big and small), Polar bear (big and small), Bunny, Cat, Pig (big and small), Fox
- Leeke Bono (beaver), Myu (cat), Corgi (dog), Erini (elephant), Beco (pig) and Picurin (bear)
- Luts Minimee Zuzu Delf figurines
- MisticUnicorn The Mushroom Peddler Wonderlings (various animals), Mini-Wonderlings (various animals; textured resin, more animal than anthro), Spark the Wyvern (dragon), Buglings (various insects, lack required joints)
- Tendres de Chimère Zouïe (fish), Fenouil (rabbit)
- tam★tam by ozaru-cozaru/PetLovers
- Wilde Imagination Mouette (skunk)
Artist dolls
All dolls allowed on Den of Angels must adhere to the forum criteria. Artists who have created dolls in resin should post in Ask the Moderators] with information about their dolls before posting them on the forum.
Being listed as off-topic does not imply a negative judgment against the makers or sculpts. They simply do not fit the focus of our forum and have been ruled off-topic. Forums to discuss them: Lunar Ark, Junky Spot, Blythe Kingdom
Banned Dolls
For a list of banned dolls/bootlegs, please read banned dolls.
